diff --git a/files/classes/user.py b/files/classes/user.py
index a5ef20423..ec70a40ed 100644
--- a/files/classes/user.py
+++ b/files/classes/user.py
@@ -426,7 +426,7 @@ class User(Base):
 	@property
 	@lazy
 	def not_post_notifications_count(self):
-		return self.notifications_count - self.post_notifications_count
+		return self.notifications_count - self.post_notifications_count - self.reddit_notifications_count
 
 	@property
 	@lazy
diff --git a/files/templates/notifications.html b/files/templates/notifications.html
index d33c502c3..6a4186b45 100644
--- a/files/templates/notifications.html
+++ b/files/templates/notifications.html
@@ -17,7 +17,7 @@
 	<ul class="nav settings-nav" style="padding:0 30px;">
 	<li class="nav-item">
 		<a class="nav-link py-3{% if not '=true' in request.full_path %} active{% endif %}" href="/notifications">
-		All {% if v.not_post_notifications_count - v.reddit_notifications_count %} <span class="font-weight-bold" style="color:red">({{v.not_post_notifications_count - v.reddit_notifications_count}})</span>{% endif %}
+		All {% if v.not_post_notifications_count %} <span class="font-weight-bold" style="color:red">({{v.not_post_notifications_count}})</span>{% endif %}
 		</a>
 	</li>
 	<li class="nav-item">